Leveraging Underinsured and Uninsured Casualty Losses: A Guide for Policyholders

Brian Evans, PA, CPAU, FSRT, WRT, OSHA30 • February 1, 2024

When disaster strikes and property is damaged or destroyed, navigating the aftermath can be daunting for any policyholder. Far too often property is under or uninsured. In these cases, it’s important for property owners to understand what resources are available to them to address their financial losses.

What Is a Casualty Loss?


Casualty loss, in the realm of insurance and taxes, refers to the unexpected and sudden damage or destruction of property. To qualify as a casualty loss, the event must be unforeseen, sudden, and accidental. Typically, these types of losses will be paid for through property insurance policies which are purchased for that particular property. However, if someone sustains an under-or-uninsured loss, understanding when and how those losses can be claimed as loss of income for tax purposes may be their only financial recourse to recover that loss. 


Casualty Loss on Rental Property Explained


Defined by Section 165 of the United States Code under Title 26 A, casualty loss comes with specific requirements outlined by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Three types of IRS casualty losses exist: federal, disaster, and qualified disaster losses. Federal loss applies to property in a state receiving a federal disaster declaration with subsequent damage.


Examples of Qualified Disaster Loss


See
IRS.gov/DisasterTaxRelief for date-specific declarations associated with these disasters and for more information.


Limitation on Personal Casualty and Theft Losses (the "$100 and 10% rules")


Personal casualty and theft losses of an individual, sustained in a tax year beginning after 2017, are deductible only to the extent that the losses are attributable to a federally declared disaster. Personal casualty and theft losses attributable to a federally declared disaster are subject to the $100 per casualty and 10% of your adjusted gross income (AGI) reductions unless they are attributable to a qualified disaster loss. Personal casualty and theft losses attributable to a qualified disaster loss are not subject to the 10% of the AGI reduction and the $100 reduction is increased to $500. An exception to the rule above, limiting the personal casualty and theft loss deduction to losses attributable to a federally declared disaster, applies if you have personal casualty gains for the tax year.


How to Claim a Casualty Loss as a Tax Deduction


Claiming a casualty loss involves specific steps and adherence to IRS rules:

  1. Tax Deduction:
  2. Report losses on IRS Form 4684.
  3. Claim losses as itemized deductions on Schedule A (Form 1040).
  4. Fill out Form 1040-X for refund determination.
  5. Adhere to the $100 and 10% rules set by the IRS.
  6. Calculation:
  • Determine the amount of casualty loss.
  • Deduct $100 from each amount, add the resulting values.
  • Calculate adjusted gross income (AGI).
  • Deduct 10% of AGI from the total loss for the final deduction amount.


Points to Remember:

  • Deductions should comply with the $100 and 10% rules.
  • Qualified disaster losses have a $500 deduction and are exempt from the 10% rule.
  • Multiple property owners can file separately, but joint filers should deduct the loss for one person.


Limitations


IRS casualty loss deductions face specific limitations:

  • Damage from non-federal disasters is subject to maximum insurance coverage.
  • No deduction if the net loss is less than 10% of AGI.
  • Recovered deductible losses should be included as income in the recovery year.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Casualty Losses


  • Are insurance proceeds from a casualty loss taxable?

No, insurance proceeds are generally not taxable as they are not considered income.


  • Are casualty losses deductible?

Yes, but the casualty must be sudden, unforeseen, and not fully covered by insurance.


  • How to claim a casualty loss on taxes?

Report losses on Form 4684, file Form 1040, and follow deduction rules.


Understanding IRS tax rules following a casualty loss can be essential for policyholders navigating the aftermath of these unexpected events. By following the correct procedures and rules, taxpayers can maximize their benefits, especially when insurance coverage falls short. For more information on IRS tax rules and application for deductible losses, see
IRS Publication 547 (2022), Casualties, Disasters, and Thefts or consult with a qualified tax attorney and accountant.


As always, reach out to us at 929.999.4674 or email us at info@EasternPublic.com for help navigating property insurance claims.


Eastern Public is a complete property insurance claims and risk management firm based in New York. With over 20 years of experience, we are licensed to serve clients in the greater New York City area and across the East Coast, including New York, New Jersey,  Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Vermont, Maine, Rhode Island, DC, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Kentucky, and Georgia. For 24/7 claims advice and service, contact us at (929) 999.4674 or info@EasternPublic.com .

Our Work

Value of Historic Finishes in Manhattan condominium  - Eastern Public
April 24, 2020
To make a luxury property claim, you need an experienced manager to handle the details and negotiate with the insurance company.
More Case Studies
Value of Historic Finishes in Manhattan condominium  - Eastern Public
April 24, 2020
To make a luxury property claim, you need an experienced manager to handle the details and negotiate with the insurance company.
Business income loss can include missed opportunities - Eastern Public
March 10, 2020
Eastern Public ensures your security with full coverage post-sewer line backup, ensuring material damage and lost revenue recovery for apparel retailers.
Accounting for Shared Costs at Eastern Public
March 10, 2020
When a costly air conditioning system failure occurred in a luxury residential condominium building, Eastern Public helped by managing the scope, responsibilities, and communications needed to restore common areas.
More Case Studies

News & Press

By Brian Evans September 30, 2024
Eastern Public helps homeowners and businesses affected by Hurricane Helene navigate their property insurance claims.
By Brian Evans September 15, 2024
The 2024 Annual Conference brought together professionals from the insurance claims and public adjusting fields for two days of knowledge sharing, certification, and networking. Held on September 12-13, the conference featured a mix of educational sessions, certification opportunities, and industry updates. The conference kicked off at TWA hotel and events center with a certification for appraisers and umpires, a valuable credential for professionals in the claims adjustment field. Robert Norton, CPCU, AIC of General Adjusting Services, and Jonathan Wilkofsky, Esq. of Wilkofsky, Friedman, Karel & Cummins and general counsel for the Insurance Appraisal and Umpire Association , led the "Appraiser & Umpire Certification Course Prep." This session provided attendees with essential preparatory knowledge ahead of the formal certification course. Norton and Wilkofsky shared their expertise, preparing participants for the complex scenarios they may face as certified professionals in their respective fields. The course provided a deep dive into practical and legal issues appraisers and umpires encounter in claims. This training served as a guide for those looking to further their professional qualifications and understanding of the appraisal process. After a brief break, participants had the option to take the certification exam, a significant step toward advancing their careers as insurance appraisers and umpires. The day wrapped up with a reception at the Sunken Lounge , generously sponsored by ALE Pro Insurance Logistics . Attendees enjoyed a lively hour of networking, refreshments, and industry discussions, setting the tone for the next day’s events. The second day of the conference took place at the 1962 Ballroom, starting early with breakfast and a robust lineup of educational presentations and discussions. Johnathan Lerner, Esq. of Lerner, Arnold & Winston, LLP , led a session titled "Insurable Interests: Navigating the Condo/Co-op and Landlord/Tenant Landscape." Lerner’s insights were particularly valuable for adjusters working in urban markets with intricate property arrangements. Katherine Barone and Jodie Papa from National Fire Adjustment Co., Inc. tackled challenging claims issues in "Advanced Claims Issues: Exploring Broad Evidence, Standard Fire Policy, and Moderation Covered Issues," focusing on the nuances of the Standard Fire Policy and broad evidence doctrine. Their session provided practical advice for their uses and addressed how they can affect the property claims process. The event gave way for brief presentations from the events generous sponsors including Archer Inventory , Total Restoration Inc. , Wilkofsky, Friedman, Karel & Cummins , ALE Pro , Lerner, Arnold and Winston, LLP , We Dry USA , Merlin Law Group , American Dry Cleaners , Strongwater Restoration and Kangaroo Packouts . Later in the morning, Matt Grossbard from Contango IT took the stage to demystify cyber insurance. As cyber threats continue to rise, understanding the coverage nuances of these policies is critical for professionals across the industry. Grossbard’s session covered a broad range of issues and provided strategies, tools, information to help educate attendees on the ways they can protect their clients and businesses from cybercrimes. During a working lunch, Jonathan Wilkofsky, Esq., provided an important ethics update for public adjusters in his session "Ethics Update for Public Adjusters," reinforcing best practices and ethical standards that adjusters must adhere to in an increasingly complex claims landscape. It covered changes to the NY Regulation 10, requirements for PA contracts, legal solicitation practices, and more. One of the most anticipated sessions was with Dennis Artese, Esq . and Grant Brown, Esq . from Anderson Kill , P.C., and Ronald Papa, SPPA of National Fire Adjustment Co., Inc ., discussing real-world case studies on claim adjustments and coverage issues following back-to-back hurricanes that affected a large complex of buildings. This provided invaluable lessons for attendees who manage large-scale disaster claims and insight into advance claims handling challenges and procedures. The NYPAA also introduced www.NewYorkBadFaith.com , a dedicated platform aimed at gathering stories from victims of insurance carrier bad faith in New York. The website will also serve as a fundraising tool to support lobbying efforts for establishing a private cause of action for consumers impacted by bad faith practices. The conference concluded with closing remarks, highlighting the significant growth of NYPAA and the organization’s continued efforts to support the professional development of New York public adjusters. The event reaffirmed NYPAA’s commitment to keeping members informed about industry trends and legislative developments. This year’s conference was a success, offering attendees a blend of practical training, critical industry updates, and opportunities for professional growth and networking. There were many new supporters and return attendees making this year’s 2024 NYPAA Annual Conference the most well attended in the association's history. Whether earning certification or gaining new insights into claims management and coverage, participants walked away better equipped to navigate the challenges of the evolving insurance claims landscape. As a leader in the public adjustment claims industry, and premiere provider of claims management services in New York City and beyond, Eastern Public, LLC was proud to have all our public adjusters attend this year's event. Taking advantage of the ongoing education and benefits provided through the New York Public Adjusters Association are just one of the ways that we ensure our adjusters remain the most knowledgeable and reliable in the industry. Contact us today to learn more about the ways that we can help you and your clients.
Earthquake in NYC, New Jersey
By Brian Evans, PA, CPAU, FSRT, WRT, OSHA30 April 5, 2024
CEO and Adjuster Brian Evans breaks down Earth movement exclusions in insurance policies.
More News & Press
Share by: